On top of the RDB mountain
- By Jack Vaughan, Lana Gates
- June 5, 2001
Who is first in relational databases today? There has been some trading of places (and some slicing and dicing of market definitions) but, with Informix, CA-Ingres and Sybase less visibly vibrant, IBM and Oracle can claim the top of the enterprise RDBMS bill.
"Oracle for the first time exceeded IBM in overall DBMS revenue in 1997," said Merv Adrian, a vice president in the Santa Clara, Calif., offices of Giga Information Group, a Norwell, Mass.-based consulting firm. "But IBM stormed back in 1998." On the NT platform, he said, "Microsoft lost its lead in 1997 to Oracle, and failed to win it back in 1998.
"The market has clearly identified the two top-tier players -- IBM
and Oracle," said Adrian at the recent GigaWorld IT Forum held in Scottsdale,
This database prowess, competitors are quick to assert, could
be a drawback for Oracle. A principal issue: Does the business logic
integral to the system go with the database or on an application server?
The future, say Adrian and others, is to isolate such logic from the
In 1998, Oracle pushed its application server as the place for
such logic, but this year it has also vigorously promoted the Oracle
8i database. Some analysts have said the company hopes to tie applications
more closely to its database again. "There are two completely different
management chains that merge at Larry [Ellison]," said Carl Zetie, senior
industry analyst at Giga. In this regard, Zetie posits a variation on
the slogan "Internet changes everything." Rephrased, it is "Ellison
"Even though Oracle has embraced the application server, the
positioning of 8i is still fuzzy," said Giga's Adrian. "Oracle misses
a lot of potential with its application server because they don't acknowledge
that people might use an application without an Oracle database.
"But even though the positioning isn't right there, they have
an application server -- Microsoft doesn't," opines Adrian.
"The fundamental change we are about to undergo in the database
market is the reversal of the decade-long trend of moving logic into
the database," he added.
Although sometimes allied with Oracle for Java (and against
Microsoft), IBM is heatedly contesting Oracle's RDBMS position -- in
fact, some analysts suggest Oracle has lately turned its competitive
sight somewhat more toward IBM and less toward Microsoft. Said rival
Steve Mills, general manager of IBM's Software Solutions Division, "Oracle
is so incredibly database-centric in their thinking, it's hard for them
to deliver things without the database."
A motto for the company is often "never lose the database sale," said
Giga's Zetie. "It's tattooed on their foreheads." This comment is heard
again and again when surveying industry pundits on Oracle application
-- Lana Gates and Jack Vaughan
Jack Vaughan is former Editor-at-Large at Application Development Trends magazine.
Lana Gates is a freelance writer based in Mesa, Arizona. She can be reached via e-mail at [email protected].